|
An unfortunate result of 40 years of space activity is that there are now about 150,000 pieces of space junk orbiting the Earth in the 1 to 10 cm size range beneath 1500 km altitude. These items range from the explosive bolts and fairings we used to see in the Walter Cronkite coverage to 50,000 frozen marbles of sodium potassium reactor coolant, probably the result of kicking reactor cores into higher disposal orbits. The same spirit that fills New Mexico arroyos with junk cars and refrigerators has been operating in space! Just like those arroyos, space is a commons, but we are polluting it.
The 1 to 10-cm range is important. Below 1 cm, Whipple shields can protect spacecraft, and above 10cm, the pieces are few, their orbits are known and a well-timed evasive maneuver can avoid them. In the middle range, debris are now sufficiently dense to threaten long-term space missions with large exposed cross-section.
Because the sources of the junk were originally launched from Earth in many different directions, a satellite placed in orbit today can expect to see debris coming at it at with a relative speed of up to 27,000 miles per hour. Much faster than bullets out of the highest-performance research guns on Earth, a fleck of paint the size of a small sequin at this speed packs the energy of a 12-pound barbell dropped from a second-floor window, and a "BB" pellet has the same energy as a 100-pound anvil dropped off a seven-story building. Worse yet, debris in the very popular 800-1100 km-high orbit band stay around for several thousand years.
However, up to now, it has been thought nothing could really be done about the problem except to stop making more debris.
A Solution called ORION
Photonic Associates of Santa Fe, NM has invented a laser debris sweeper. Called "ORION" by NASA, it is based on the fact that only a small change to the speed of an orbiting object can make it re-enter the atmosphere and burn up. For low-Earth-orbit debris, about a 3% change is enough. With hardware we can build today, it should take two years to clear out space.
A study team convened by NASA verified that the concept would work [see bibliography].
A high intensity pulsed laser can give this small velocity change to a debris object at great distance by turning its surface into a pulse jet, vaporizing a few-atoms-thick layer with each pulse and applying thrust to slow it down as effectively as if a tiny rocket motor were attached. This is a very efficient process, since only a small fraction of the object needs to be vaporized by the laser Ð its own speed provides most of the energy required to destroy it.
There is no hazard from the re-entering objects, which are much too small to reach the ground before being completely vaporized.
The laser station consists of four parts: a sensitive detector to see the debris at twilight and dawn, a high power repetitively pulsed laser, a large telescope mirror to focus the beam on the debris, plus a "rubber mirror" and "guidestar" laser to counteract the twinkle effect of the atmosphere and produce a good focus.
Why do we want to struggle with the atmosphere when we could put the laser in space? The $10,000 per pound cost of putting anything in orbit, let alone maintaining it, is the main reason.
Finding the debris
One way of initially boresighting the debris is a very sensitive detector invented by Cheng Ho and Bill Priedhorsky at Los Alamos National Lab, which can see these small debris illuminated by sunlight at dawn or dusk at a range of by imaging and counting individual photons. Modifications will permit it to work at 1500km range. A small, short-pulse tracking laser can help compute an orbit for each object in 3 dimensions which is accurate enough for the ORION laser to later find and act on the object in the dark. This final process involves expanding the ORION beam footprint to match the track uncertainty, using its beam as target illuminator, then progressively narrowing the footprint with the aid of a quadrant detector and adaptive optics.
The ORION laser and beam director
A laser firing twice per second with an average power of just 30 kilowatts will do the trick. Each pulse of 15 kilojoules energy will have a duration of 10 billionths of a second. Even a six-meter-diameter mirror can only focus the laser beam to a spot which is larger than the debris Ð but still able to apply several hundred megawatts per square centimeter to the debris surface during the pulse to produce the flash-jet. Maximum range is about 1500 km.
Adaptive optics
A rubber mirror within the beam director corrects the beam several thousand times a second for twinkling due to turbulence in the air above.
Information needed to correct for turbulence comes by comparing light from a star or any other very small object in the field of view, which is effectively a plane wave in space, with a flat reference surface. Since stars aren't always where you want them, an artificial star, made by exciting the sodium layer 90 km up with a separate orange "guidestar" laser beam, is used. Finally, a "windage" correction has to be applied to account for the fact that the debris object will have moved several meters ahead by the time the laser beam reaches it.
Footnotes
The ORION study was cosponsored by the USAF Space Command, directed by Ivan Bekey (then with NASA headquarters) and managed by Dr. Jon Campbell (NASA Marshall Spaceflight Center). Participants in the study were the author of the concept, Dr. Claude Phipps (Photonic Associates), Dr. Jim Reilly (Northeast Science and Technology, East Sandwich MA), Dr. Sid Sridharan (MIT Lincoln Labs), Dr. John Rather (then with NASA headquarters), Dr. Glen Zeiders (then with AmDyn Corporation) and Dr. David Spencer (USAF Phillips Laboratory).
To find out more...
1.I. Bekey, "Orion's laser: Hunting space debris", Aerospace America, May 1997, pp.38-44
2.C. R. Phipps and J. P. Reilly, "ORION: Clearing near-Earth space debris in two years using a 30-kW repetitively-pulsed laser", Proc. XI International Symposium on Gas Flow and Chemical Lasers and High Power Laser Conference, Edinburgh, 30 August, 1996, SPIE 3092, pp728-31 (1997)
3. J.W. Campbell, ed., Project ORION: Orbital Debris Removal Using Ground-Based Sensors and Lasers, NASA Marshall Spaceflight Center Technical Memorandum 108522 October 1996
4. C. R. Phipps, H. Friedman, D. Gavel, J. Murray, G. Albrecht, E. V. George, C. Ho, W. Priedhorsky, M. M. Michaelis and J. P. Reilly, "ORION: Clearing near-Earth space debris using a 20-kW, 530-nm, Earth-based, repetitively pulsed laser", Laser and Particle Beams, 14 (1) (1996) pp. 1-44
5. C. R. Phipps, Proceedings of the 11th International Workshop on Laser Interaction and Related Plasma Phenomena, Monterey, October 25-29, 1993, Laser and Particle Beams, 13(1) (1995) pp. 33-41
... or contact the author directly at CRPhipps@aol.com or crphipps@ni.net. He will be happy to send you a copy of the NASA TM or other papers, while they last.
Dr. Claude Phipps, SB MIT 61, SM MIT 63, received his Ph.D. from Stanford University in 1972. He developed the ORION concept while a senior R&D staff member at Los Alamos National Labs. He has numerous publications, including 31 invited presentations and a technical book chapter, on laser-surface interactions, laser system design and plasma physics. He presently heads a consulting firm, Photonic Associates of Santa Fe.
|